As a teenager I was besotted with the then (in my eyes) muscle hunk Sylvester Stallone. Those arms! Those eyes! Those muscles! He made a young teenage heart beat faster I can tell you! I still cry whenever I see Rocky, in the sequence where he has won his fight and shouts to Aidrian that he loves her - it's not what he says at all, its the music in the background that makes me come over all emotional - big softie me.
I first saw that cheeky cockney style smile of Jason Statham in Lock Stock and two Smoking Barrels - hated that film but watched it just for him! In the Transporter trilogy I find myself watching him rather than the film, as in a suit he looks gorgeous... Can you see a theme to my favourite actors - muscles, biceps, dark eyes??
I love my men to be men in films and he certainly is all man! He has a gorgeous smile and any man that can do the splits and high kick like that gets my vote.
So I am sorry my choice is not based on their contribution to the film industry, talent and ability for if it had have been it would have gone to Dustin Hoffman. My apologies Mr Hoffman.